Man considering the best way to hire an external SEO agency

What’s the best way to hire an external SEO agency and what should I look for?

The best way to hire an external SEO agency is to start by setting clear business goals, assessing your website’s health, and looking for agencies that offer a strategy tailored to your needs. Make sure they provide clear and regular reporting, offer flexible contracts, and have the technical skills to handle both traditional search engines and new AI-driven search results.

The right SEO partner can help turn your website into a steady source of new revenue. The wrong one can leave you stuck with high costs, a poor user experience, and little to show for your investment.

Whether you are hiring an agency for the first time or looking to switch, here’s a simple guide to help you choose the right SEO partner and show you what to look out for.

Define your business goals before you start looking

Before you reach out to any SEO agency, work out if you need more local customers, want to grow your online store, or need to fix technical issues on your website. Your main business goal will shape the type of campaign and budget you need.

Agencies can’t build a good strategy around a vague goal like “getting more traffic.” Getting lots of visitors who aren’t interested in your business won’t help you grow. Instead, focus on clear, measurable results that matter to your business.

  • Local reach: Dominating Google Maps and local search results (aiming for the top three local map spots) to drive phone calls and enquiries in specific areas. This is ideal for service-based and local brick-and-mortar businesses that rely on walk-in traffic.
  • Ecommerce and product sales: Optimising product pages and free Google Shopping listings to capture high-intent buyers ready to purchase.
    Foundational cleanup: Conducting a comprehensive SEO audit to resolve technical issues, crawl errors, or outdated content before scaling up.
  • Generative engine optimisation (GEO or AI search): Optimising your website to appear in AI search engines such as Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, and Perplexity. If this is important to you, make it a clear goal from the start so you can choose an agency that knows how to set up your content for these AI search opportunities. It’s a whole new approach compared to traditional SEO work.

What should I look for in a high-performing SEO agency?

When you’re comparing SEO agencies, look for those who offer a strategy built around your business, clear reporting on results, strong technical skills with your website platform (like WordPress), and who keep up with the latest changes in search, including AI.

Use these core criteria to vet your shortlist:

1. Tailored strategy over rigid monthly checklists

Avoid agencies that treat every client the same. Every website is different, with its own strengths and challenges, and every target audience responds differently. Choose an agency that focuses on the most important tasks first and puts most of your budget into work that actually makes a difference, not just ticking boxes.

2. Readiness for AI search and Large Language Models (LLMs)

People now use search in new ways, including asking questions to AI tools, so it’s important your business appears in AI search engines like Google AI Overviews and ChatGPT. Your SEO agency should help your website show up as a trusted source by focusing on:

  • Advanced schema markup and structured data: Invisible code that helps LLMs crawl, categorise, and accurately read your business and service data.
  • Conversational, question-driven content: Structuring pages and articles to directly answer the real questions your audience asks.
  • Brand mentions and authority: Earning mentions on trusted third-party websites so AI models recognise your brand as credible.

3. Current technical expertise

Technical SEO is what helps search engines find and understand your website. If they can’t do that, your content won’t show up in search results regardless of how good it is. Your agency should handle things like sitemaps, site speed, schema markup, and proactively fixing errors to minimise website downtime. If you use WordPress, it’s important to work with an agency that knows WordPress inside and out, so that software updates don’t cause problems.

4. Clear, results-focused reporting

Numbers like “impressions” don’t help your business grow if they don’t lead to real results. Your agency must set up proper tracking and give you clear, simple reports. You should always know which keywords are being tracked, where your leads are coming from, and what your return on investment is.

5. Ethical link building and brand authority

Backlinks are still important for building trust with search engines. Ask agencies how they get links to your website. Look for quality over quantity, such as getting links from trusted industry sites rather than cheap or spammy sources that could actually hurt your rankings.

6. Flexible contracts (no long-term lock-ins)

SEO takes time to work, usually 6 to 12 months to see strong results. Your agency should keep you as a client by delivering results, not by locking you into long contracts. Look for flexible, month-to-month agreements.

7. Realistic pricing matched to your market

Make sure you know what a realistic budget looks like for your business and your industry.

Business scale

Small businesses

Medium businesses

Large brands

Typical SEO investment

$3,000 – $5,000 / month

$5,000+ / month

$20,000 – $50,000 / month

Primary focus

Local reach, Google Business Profile, foundational technical health, and core service keywords.

Competitive regional/national keywords, ongoing content creation, link building, and detailed ROI tracking.

High-competition national or international markets, large-scale technical architecture, and broad digital authority.

What essential questions should I ask an SEO agency before signing?

When you speak with an agency, ask them how they review your website at the start, how they adjust their approach when things change, who will be working on your account, and how they track new leads. For example:

  • “Will your SEO agency start with a comprehensive SEO audit?” – A trustworthy agency diagnoses your technical, on-page, and off-page performance, as well as your competitive landscape, before proposing a solution.
  • “How does your SEO agency decide which tasks to focus on each month?” – Look for an answer centred on the impact to your business and return on investment, rather than a fixed checklist.
  • “How does your SEO agency optimise websites for AI search engines and ChatGPT?” – Ensure they have a solid technical and content strategy for generative search, not just traditional keyword rankings.
  • “What happens if you want to pause or cancel your SEO service?” – Confirm there are no punitive 12-month lock-in clauses. A good agency will allow you to cancel with reasonable notice, and no offboarding fees.

What are red flags to avoid when hiring an external SEO agency?

Be wary of any SEO agency that promises top Google rankings (without details), quick results, vague strategy, or uses cheap automated link-building tools.

  • No agency controls Google’s algorithm, so unquantified guarantees about rankings or traffic volumes are a hallmark of dishonest sales tactics.
  • Very cheap SEO packages usually mean corners are being cut or the work is being conducted by inexperienced people. Good SEO needs skilled people, not just automated tools, and poor-quality work can actually damage your website and business reputations.
  • If an agency focuses only on keywords on your website and ignores how your business is mentioned elsewhere online, that’s a red flag. Search engines look at your reputation across the web, so it’s important your agency helps build your brand’s credibility beyond your own site.
  • Ranking for popular keywords might look good, but it doesn’t always bring in new customers. Make sure your agency focuses on keywords that attract people genuinely interested in your services and who are likely to convert, not just on big traffic numbers.
  • Some agencies ignore new AI search features, while others promise AI success that sounds too good to be true. The best results come from having a solid website, clear information, and building real trust in your brand that serves both SEO and AI search engines.

Frequently asked questions about hiring an SEO agency

How long does it take to see results from an SEO agency?

Most businesses start to see real improvements in rankings and leads after about 6 months of steady SEO work, with results building up over 6 to 12 months. Some technical fixes and proper configuration of your SEO software can deliver early wins, but consistently ranking at the top for tough keywords requires ongoing effort.

Should I start with an SEO audit or an ongoing SEO plan?

If you’re not sure what’s stopping your website from growing, or you want to see what an agency can do, start with an SEO audit. This will show you any technical problems, missing content, and opportunities to get ahead of your competitors. Once you know what needs fixing, you can move on to a monthly SEO plan.

How much of my SEO budget goes toward actual work?

With a good agency, about 85% of your monthly budget should go directly to the work completed by experienced SEO specialists, such as strategy, technical updates, content, and link building. The rest covers outlays for things like backlinks and business directory listings.

Ready to grow your organic visibility?

At GO Creative, we’ve been helping Australian businesses build strong websites and grow their search visibility since 2001. We specialise in WordPress SEO, technical audits, and search strategies that work with the latest AI tools. Every campaign is built around your business goals, with clear reporting and flexible, no-lock-in plans.

Book a free strategy chat with our team today to discuss your business goals and identify your biggest opportunities in both traditional SEO and AI results.

Like what you see? Share this post to...
Secret Link